Wednesday, 20 May 2009

Concern rises in Vietnam over fiscal deficit

By John Ruwitch and Umesh Desai

HANOI/HONG KONG, May 20 (Reuters) - Vietnam's state treasury has failed to raise much money through bond issues this year, sparking concerns about how Hanoi will fund a budget gap which could widen to a tenth of gross domestic product (GDP).

In an attempt to dig the country out of an economic hole that caused first quarter GDP growth to stumble to its slowest pace in a decade, the state has unveiled a string of economic stimulus measures that the government says will cost around $8 billion.

But the economic slowdown has staunched the flow of its main revenue sources -- proceeds from crude oil exports and taxes -- raising questions about how the shortfall will be met.

'It's a really big question, if not the biggest one for the economy,' said Vu Thanh Tu Anh, director of research at the Fulbright School in Ho Chi Minh City.

Parliament, which opened on Wednesday, will take up the budget deficit when it meets over the next month, and state media have already reported some debate among members over how much of a deficit is acceptible.

The government projects the 2009 budget shortfall at 8 percent of GDP, although the Asian Development Bank estimates it will be closer to 10 percent. The fiscal deficit was at 4.7 percent in 2008 and 5.5 percent in 2007.

Other Southeast Asian countries also face ballooning budget shortfalls due to increased spending and falling revenue, but they still compare significantly lower than Vietnam.

The Philippines and Indonesia, which have tapped the global bond market this year to secure funding for their budgets, have both forecast a shortfalls of 2.5 percent of GDP.

'In our view, some adjustments to the fiscal strategy for 2009 are needed to contain the size of the deficit and safeguard macroeconomic stability,' said Benedict Bingham, the International Monetary Fund's senior resident representative.

YIELD MISMATCH

So far this year Hanoi has sold about $236 million in dollar- and dong-denominated bonds, a fraction of what the Communist Party's newspaper Nhan Dan said in March was the government's fundraising target of 55.2 trillion dong ($3.11 billion).

On Wednesday, the government asked parliament to approve the sale additional bonds worth 20 trillion dong ($1.13 billion).

In latest bond auction last week, the Treasury failed to sell 2 trillion dong worth of three- and five-year bonds with bidders seeking yields that were 70 and 80 basis points higher than the state was prepared to go.

The series of unsuccessful auctions come as state revenues fell 20 percent to 86.27 trillion dong in the first quarter from a year earlier.

'The tricky part is how long can they sustain this shortfall. Clearly, they are in need of money,' said Khalil Belhimeur, fixed income strategist with Standard Chartered Bank.

'Eventually they will have to raise their stop out rates and that's what will happen in the near to medium term.'

Analysts say the government may be wary about accepting higher yields as it may go against its current easy monetary stance, while banks themselves are reluctant to park funds in bonds as interest rate subsidies from the stimulus package have boosted demand for loans.

But not everybody is convinced that the government faces a budget crisis.

Ratings analyst Kim Eng Tan of Standard & Poor's estimated that about a fifth of the $8 billion stimulus price tag was either already budgeted for or did not require upfront cash.

ADB's country director for Vietnam, Ayumi Konishi, told Reuters the state could also raise an additional $1 billion-$1.5 billion by asking donors to pony up more money, or accelerate disbursements already in the pipeline.

He added that most of the stimulus measures were temporary fixes and that they would not have much impact into the future. ADB expects deficit to narrow to around 5 percent next year.

'We aren't really worried too much,' he told Reuters. 'But of course it's certainly cause for very careful fiscal management.'

($1 = 17,780 dong)

(Editing by Kazunori Takada)

((john.ruwitch@thomsonreuters.com; +84 4 3825 9623; Reuters Messaging: john.ruwitch.reuters.com@reuters.net)) Keywords: VIETNAM ECONOMY/BUDGET

(If you have a query or comment on this story, send an email to news.feedback.asia@thomsonreuters.com)

COPYRIGHT

Copyright Thomson Reuters 2009. All rights reserved.

Tuesday, 19 May 2009

Vietnam reports first death from recent cholera outbreak

HANOI (AFP) — Vietnam has recorded its first cholera death during an outbreak that has spread to 11 out of 63 provinces and cities across the communist nation, the health ministry said on Tuesday.

The 50-year-old victim from northern Ninh Binh province died on May 12 a few hours after hospitalisation, said a Ministry of Health website report.

The victim was an alcoholic who tested positive for vibrio cholera bacteria. He had diarrhoea and serious dehydration, the ministry said.

It added that a total of 53 patients have been confirmed with cholera since April 20, while more than 500 others had acute diarrhoea.

In March and April last year the country battled cholera outbreaks which hit Hanoi, Ho Chi Minh City and 16 other provinces. More than 100 people were infected but no fatalities were reported.

Vietnam has a long standing problem with food safety and hygiene.

Authorities in Hanoi have temporarily closed at least a dozen dog slaughterhouses -- where the popular meat is prepared -- over fears their unhygienic conditions may help spread cholera bacteria to people, an official said Monday.

Cholera is an acute intestinal infection transmitted through water or food contaminated with the bacteria vibrio cholera. It causes diarrhoea and dehydration and can lead to kidney failure and death if untreated.

The World Health Organization (WHO) says cholera can be easily avoided through good hygiene, especially by washing hands with soap after using the toilet.

The WHO on Tuesday referred to a 2006 survey of rural sanitation that found only 12 percent of people washed their hands before eating, 15.5 percent washed after urinating, and 16.9 percent cleaned their hands after defecating. The survey was carried out by Vietnam's Department of Preventative Medicine and Environment.

Bacteria from the faeces of a contaminated person are one of the main sources of cholera contamination, the WHO says.

As part of its joining the World Trade Organization two years ago, Vietnam's food safety needs to adapt to international standards, WHO said.

"Coordination of activities to ensure safe practices into the entire food chain is a challenging task for Vietnam's government," it said.

Copyright © 2009 AFP. All rights reserved.

Vietnam plans ban on dancing to karaoke

HO CHI MINH CITY (AFP) — It is early evening and another night of singing has begun in earnest at Style Karaoke, a plush club where high-flyers in Vietnam's commercial capital come to let off steam.

Music blasts from behind the glass doors of the small rooms where groups gather to sing and, as the rhythm takes hold, to dance.

And that, the communist government says, is the problem.

It wants to ban dancing at karaoke bars in what reports have said is a bid to limit drug use.

The Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism posted the proposed ban on its website last month and invited public comment on the move, its latest attempt to clamp down on lawlessness at the popular singing venues.

But at Style and other neon-lit clubs on Su Van Hanh street, the heart of karaoke entertainment in the city formerly known as Saigon, the proposal is dismissed as unworkable.

"I think it's not feasible because these people who go to karaoke want to relieve their stress," says Dang Duy Thanh, the gel-haired manager of Style.

"If we just force them to stay there singing without feeling comfortable, that's not right".

Le Anh Tuyen, head of the culture ministry's legal department, reportedly sees things differently.

Tuyen, who five years ago warned that karaoke was linked to prostitution, was quoted by the VietnamNet news website last month as saying the drug ecstasy would be used in karaoke rooms if dancing was not banned.

"Ecstasy always goes with wine and music," he said. "In my opinion, karaoke is a cultural activity which is always latent with social evils."

Tuyen did not respond to AFP's requests for an interview.

Ecstasy became popular around the world at "rave" dance parties.

Tuyen told VietnamNet the government has statistics about the use of ecstasy at karaoke bars, but the report gave no data.

"I'm sure the real number of cases is higher than in our statistics. Evils will not be prevented without banning dancing," he was quoted as saying. "In our country, karaoke often goes with ecstasy and prostitution."

Karaoke workers on Su Van Hanh street said ecstasy could be found in some clubs -- but not theirs.

"Not all karaokes allow the use of ecstasy," says Thanh, whose club targets middle to higher-class customers and charges about double the room rate of nearby singing clubs like Karaoke K-T.

"This is what we call 'family karaoke'," said Pham Ngoc Khanh, 40, a staffer at K-T.

He said the business, open for several years, has a loyal following of civil servants, students and workers.

"It is not karaoke with what we call 'social evils'."

Clubs in other parts of the city might be more prone to vice, he said.

"It's not right to ban us from dancing in karaoke clubs," said one K-T customer, who arrived with a laptop bag on his shoulder. "Maybe they should ban dance bars where they have prostitutes. If they just make a general ban on dancing in karaokes, it's not reasonable."

The customer declined to give his name.

Khanh, the K-T worker, said karaoke was a popular form of entertainment and a ban on dancing would be "a bit strange" for customers trying to relax.

Karaoke was introduced to Vietnam in the early 1990s. The bars are now found throughout the socially conservative nation, even in remote mountainous villages.

"It's impossible" to ban dancing, says Dang Duc Han, standing in a T-shirt, his arms folded, outside the Karaoke 64 club he manages.

If people feel in the mood they will dance, Han says as customers ride up on their motorcycles, and a child with a toy bicycle brushes against his leg.

In 2006 Vietnam banned alcohol in karaoke bars -- but in practice drinking continues -- while a year earlier it stopped issuing licences for bars, karaoke parlours and dance halls.

Earlier draft legislation even called for karaoke clubs to be shut down, after Tuyen said many served as brothels.

In his interview with VietnamNet, Tuyen admitted inspectors were not able to check karaoke clubs very often and said "people themselves must obey the rules".

Khanh, of Karaoke K-T, said officials have lost touch with reality.

"They have been sitting in a high position for quite some time," he said. "They are not realistic."

Ngo Thi Bao Ngoc, 28, a black-stockinged staffer at the Style club, said that as the number of karaokes proliferates, authorities have a hard time controlling them.

"They get confused and they don't know how to deal with it," she said.

Serious business owners will not want ecstasy on their premises because it damages their reputation while bringing no benefit, and banning dancing would not work, Ngoc said.

"Dancing is understandable. There is no reason to ban it," she said.

Copyright © 2009 AFP. All rights reserved

Sunday, 17 May 2009

Hanoi pol seeks to silence noisy wartime relic

By BEN STOCKING

HANOI, Vietnam (AP) — Each day at around 4 p.m., Hoang Thi Gai tries to lull her five-month-old grandson to sleep so that she can prepare supper. About 15 minutes later, a loudspeaker starts blaring just outside her Hanoi home.

"He starts screaming and crying and his face turns purple," said Gai, 61. "My dear boy hasn't been able to adapt."

As signs of the Vietnam War fade away in this rapidly modernizing country, one relic is hard to miss: a nationwide network of loudspeakers from which the communist government blasts propaganda at dawn and dusk, 30 minutes at a stretch, whether the public likes it or not.

Now a Web-savvy Hanoi politician wants to silence the head-rattling messages and put them on the Internet, where people can read them at their leisure.

During the Vietnam War, the loudspeakers aired crucial warnings about bombing raids. Today, they broadcast an odd mix of local news, bureaucratic trivia, communist ideology and patriotic songs.

"I must admit, for people who live near the speakers, it's a disaster. It hurts their ears," Pham Van Hien said in an interview.

Hien, 38, is chairman of the People's Committee in Hanoi's Khuong Mai commune, one of more than 500 such elected officials in the capital. And, like any good politician, he has his finger on the popular pulse. His campaign against the loudspeakers has received resounding support in Vietnamese chat rooms, blogs and newspaper Web sites.

"Imagine if you lived near a loudspeaker and someone in your family was terminally ill and had to keep hearing a song like 'There Has Never Been Such A Beautiful Day As Today,'" Hanoi resident Tran Hung wrote to the Tien Phong newspaper's online edition.

"It's cruel," he continued. "If my neighbor made that kind of noise, I would take him to court. Why does the government give itself the right to create noise pollution?"

At the Ministry of Culture, Sports and Tourism, which oversees the system, officials declined to comment on Hien's effort.

Hien says his idea has received warm reviews from some of his higher-ups in the Communist Party who are eager to embrace technology and update their party's image. But he is also careful not to push his plan too hard lest he annoy party bosses. Instead he is showing how the system can be modernized, hoping that officialdom will get the message — that people should be allowed to "choose to listen rather than be forced to listen."

Thousands of wards across Vietnam make loudspeaker broadcasts, including 577 in Hanoi alone. They tailor the content to their needs, but incorporate lots of information from the Ministry of Culture.

In Hien's ward of 20,000 people, 60 loudspeakers on utility polls broadcast messages from a tiny guard house.

On a recent day, the reader was Tran Anh Tuyet, a 33-year-old state employee. She read from a government pamphlet called "Happy Family," offering information about an upcoming national census. Then came exhortations to people to "enrich their spiritual life" by skipping TV and attending cultural events instead.

"Let's make Hanoi beautiful in the eyes of international friends," she read, urging citizens to create a "polite, cultured environment."

The broadcasts often urge listeners to follow the example of Ho Chi Minh, the father of Vietnam's communist revolution: "Live virtuously, work hard, and give your heart to the people."

Hien's Web site, The Khuong Mai News, offers everything the loudspeakers deliver, plus extra coverage ranging from floods to a Russian fortuneteller predicting Barack Obama's future.

Hien says more than half the households in his district have access to the Internet at home, and there are also several Internet cafes in the area.

He says the site has received over 800,000 hits since it went online last year. VietNamNet, an online newspaper, wrote a story about the site, and then state-run television did a story.

When the 7 a.m. loudspeaker broadcasts come on, Nguyen Thi Oanh, 23, buries her head under the blankets.

"Who cares about the news they read?" she said. "The sound is so bad, they all sound like they have a stuffy nose."

At 68, Nguyen Thi Phuong is old enough to remember the speakers in wartime.

"Whenever they warned us about air raids, we rushed to the bomb shelters," she said. "Those speakers saved many lives."

But now they're simply annoying, Phuong said. "Putting that information on the Internet is a wonderful idea."

Associated Press Writer Vu Tien Hong contributed to this story.

Copyright © 2009 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.

Saturday, 16 May 2009

Talks begin on new deal with Vietnam over adoption laws

Children's minister Barry Andrews is bidding to thrash out a new agreement after Irish couples are left in limbo.

The Irish government will ask Vietnam to re-open international adoptions on an interim basis after coming under intense pressure from prospective adoptive parents.

About 275 Irish couples who have been approved to adopt from Vietnam have been “left in limbo” after a bilateral agreement between the countries lapsed on May 1.

Barry Andrews, the minister for children, is trying to negotiate a new, stricter, agreement with Vietnam which protects children, while placating the hundreds of couples whose plans to adopt have been thrown into disarray.

Politicians from all parties are being lobbied by couples and adoption support groups to put a new deal in place.

A well-placed source said Andrews, who has been criticised for not beginning negotiations sooner, has come under pressure from senior cabinet members to get a deal in place.

The source said a legal issue dating from 2002 meant that there were concerns over the compatibility of Irish and Vietnamese law, which meant that adoptions might not be allowed to be registered under an interim arrangement. The issue has been referred to the attorney-general.

New figures released by the Adoption Board show that 182 out of 397 international adoptions registered in Ireland in 2008 were from Vietnam.

Russia was second, with 117 adoptions, while Ethiopia was third, with 26. Adoptions from Vietnam came under renewed scrutiny when America and Sweden suspended them last year, after discovering discrepancies.

The American embassy in Hanoi had detected the use of fraudulent documents and found that some orphanages offered financial incentives to workers for children made available for international adoption.

“We sent a delegation to Vietnam to inform the government about what to do next,” said Andrews.

“When we got that report, we were satisfied that there were enough distinctions in the way we operated and the way the Americans have been doing it to allow us to negotiate a new bilateral agreement.”

Andrews said Irish parents, through the Helping Hands agency in Vietnam, usually adopted relinquished, rather than abandoned, children. This made it easier for the state to establish whether the mothers had given the correct permission. “We are trying to improve standards all the time,” he said.

The government plans to enact new adoption law later this year that will ratify the Hague Convention on International Adoption. Irish couples will be able to adopt only from countries that have have ratified the convention or have state-to-state agreements with Ireland. Andrews confirmed that negotiations with Russia began several weeks ago.

Times Online

Vietnam Coach Lauds Players After Olympiakos Win

It was another night to remember in Hanoi for local fans...

Vietnam coach Henrique Calisto paid tribute to his players after watching the team defeat Olympiakos 1-0 in a friendly in Hanoi.

Neither team was at full strength for the match and it was an open and exciting game at the My Dinh Stadium.

The match looked to be heading for a goalless draw until Quang Hai intervened with just seven minutes remaining.

The midfielder’s shot took a deflection off a defender to leave substitute goalkeeper Pavel Kovac with no chance.

“The Vietnamese team played very well in this match. I am very pleased with their performance and spirits. We should be proud because we have seen the national team with national pride in their hearts,” Calisto told reporters.

“The team attacked a lot, but it is a pity that there was only one goal,” the Portuguese tactician added.

“I would like to thank everyone because they all deserve to be praised. Each player satisfied my expectations. The team will have more outstanding players and it will be stronger.”

Thursday, 14 May 2009

Vietnam Boss Blasts Preparation Ahead Of Olympiakos Match

The gaffer wants better facilities for the national team...

Vietnam coach Henrique Calisto has is less than happy with the state of the training ground ahead of Thursday’s friendly match against Olympiakos.

The Portuguese tactician has been told to use the practice field at the My Dinh Sport Complex in Hanoi.

“It turns out there are two kingdoms here – one kingdom, the Vietnam Football Federation, wants it, but the My Dinh Stadium kingdom that doesn’t allow it. It’s strange!” Calisto said, according to the Thanh Nien News.

“The team has only six training sessions before the match with Olympiakos, and just two of the sessions are major ones. That is not enough. Why don’t they create good opportunities for us?

“The My Dinh Sports Complex belongs to the nation; the My Dinh Stadium belongs to the nation; the team is the national team. Why don’t they get the best possible conditions?”

Calisto, known for his quick temper, had a whole list of complaints about what was on offer to his players.

He said, “Look at the field. It is very rough and hard for the players to practice their skills because the ball bounces too much. It’s very dangerous to practice on such a field because players can suffer injuries at any time.

“It’s strange some amateur teams can come and rent good fields here to practice on.

“I am not speaking for myself. I am speaking for the good of the national team. I will meet the manager of the My Dinh Stadium to talk about it. Why do they do this to the national team?”

Calisto has told his players to be on their guard against the Greek giants.

He added, “Playing against such a rival, you must run to your half of the field immediately when you lose control of the ball.”

GOAL.com

US on track to be top investor in Vietnam

HANOI (AFP) — The United States is on track to become the leading foreign direct investor in communist Vietnam, more than 30 years after the end of their war, the head of a US business delegation said Wednesday.

"I'm willing to wager... that within no more than three years -- and perhaps a good deal less -- the United States will be the largest foreign direct investor in Vietnam," Matthew Daley, president of the US-ASEAN Business Council, told reporters.

"I think the trend lines are clear."

He said that in the first quarter of this year, Vietnam registered about six billion dollars in foreign direct investment, more than half of which, about 3.86 billion dollars, came from American firms.

The Washington-based US-ASEAN Business Council represents more than 100 US companies. Representatives of 15 of them have joined Daley on a three-day mission that began Wednesday to explore opportunities in Vietnam.

Following the war which ended with Vietnam's reunification in 1975, the US did not lift a trade embargo until 1994. Diplomatic relations were normalised a year later.

Daley says the United States is either the sixth or 10th-ranked foreign investor in Vietnam, depending on which figures are used.

"American interest, as evidenced by investment in Vietnam, has been growing dramatically," he said.

The delegation will meet with government leaders and executives from state-owned enterprises during their mission, which is an annual event.

Daley said the presence of 15 US companies during a global economic downturn says much about their perceptions of Vietnam's potential. It also speaks to "the frame of mind of the country and the government regarding participation in these activities by the foreign business community."

Stuart Dean, regional president of GE, said his firm got "great support" from Vietnamese authorities to allow quick construction of his company's first manufacturing investment in Vietnam. The firm broke ground in Haiphong on Tuesday for a plant to build wind turbine components.

"We're excited about doing more here, particularly in the infrastructure area," he told the press conference.

Foreign businesspeople have expressed concern about the state of Vietnam's roads, utilities and other infrastructure, as well as corruption, and the extent of reform at state-owned businesses.

Hank Tomlinson, president of Chevron Vietnam, said at the same briefing that his firm and partners had already invested more than 300 million dollars towards a gas project in southern Vietnam.

The company was in the final stages of negotiations with state-owned PetroVietnam before final approval to begin engineering work, he said.

The project would then require another four billion dollars' worth of investment, 2.5 billion of that from Chevron which would make the US company "the single largest investor in Vietnam," Tomlinson said.

In June last year the US and Vietnam agreed to begin talks for a bilateral investment treaty.

Daley said he believed those negotiations would go forward under the administration of US President Barack Obama, who took office this year.

Copyright © 2009 AFP. All rights reserved.

Wednesday, 6 May 2009

Remembrance and reconciliation 55 yrs after Dien Bien Phu

HANOI (AFP) — He has a full head of dark hair. His glasses are slightly tinted, and he wears a silver chain around his neck. Retired colonel Pham Xuan Phuong carries his 80 years well.

"I am lucky to be as strong as this," says Phuong, one of a dwindling number of Vietnamese war veterans who on Thursday will mark the 55th anniversary of their victory over French colonisers at Dien Bien Phu.

The 56-day battle in a northwestern Vietnamese valley ended on May 7, 1954 and was the critical event in Vietnam's emergence as an independent nation.

During the battle, artillery boomed across the valley and there was hand-to-hand fighting. Dien Bien Phu and its surrounding hills were filled with the rotting corpses of soldiers from both sides.

Now it is a small city where celebrations are planned at a stadium to mark the victory.

Phuong said he expected other ceremonies in the capital, Hanoi, but many among the small band of survivors lack his energy and would not attend.

"Maybe most of them will stay home and watch TV," says Phuong, whose own life reflects the reversal in French-Vietnamese relations over the past 55 years.

A fluent French speaker, Phuong says he befriended one of his former enemies, General Marcel Bigeard, who returned to the battlefield 15 years ago.

Phuong is also the Vietnamese representative for Le Souvenir Francais, which maintains the graves of French war dead at home and abroad.

In Dien Bien Phu, the graves were in the thousands.

The battle started the collapse of France's colonial empire but cost an estimated 10,000 Vietnamese lives. About 3,000 soldiers of various nationalities who fought under the French flag died or disappeared.

"We won, but the price we paid was also very high," said Phuong, who commanded a company of more than 100 men throughout the fight.

All but 27 of them had died or were wounded by the time the guns suddenly fell silent and "a forest of white flags" went up from the thousands of troops from the French side who were still alive, recalled Phuong.

France's defeat led to Vietnam's division into the communist North and pro-US South, setting the stage for two more decades of war, in which Phuong also fought.

The battle against American forces and their surrogate regime cost at least three million Vietnamese and 58,000 American lives before it ended on April 30, 1975 when the country was reunified.

"I am still alive. That is unexpected luck," said Phuong, an amiable man whose eyes lock onto those of his interviewer.

Another survivor was the paratroop commander Bigeard, whom Phuong accompanied on the Frenchman's return to Dien Bien Phu.

"He was 80 when he returned. I was 65.... We were joking all the time," says the retired officer, displaying French press articles about their meeting.

"I found a new friend," he said at the government apartment he shares with his wife.

Bigeard left Phuong with a photocopied edition of his memoirs, which the Frenchman inscribed for his "comrade" in arms.

"We lived the same life in Dantesque conditions," Bigeard wrote. "Know how proud I am of you."

The personal links between Phuong and Bigeard reflect relations at a national level, where the war is something long past.

"We are dedicated to build the future," a French official said, describing relations as very good and spanning a variety of sectors.

France is Vietnam's second-biggest bilateral donor.

There are even some military ties between them. A French warship is to make an annual visit to Vietnam later this month -- and Phuong says he has been invited.

There will be no official French participation at the commemoration ceremonies in Dien Bien Phu on Thursday, the official said, but neither was there at the much grander 50th anniversary commemoration.

General Vo Nguyen Giap, the mastermind of Vietnam's victory over the French, is also not expected to attend.

Aged 97 and in frail health, Giap is second only to Vietnamese Communist Party founding father Ho Chi Minh as the most revered figure in Vietnam's recent history.

The state Vietnam News Agency reported that a delegation of foreign military attaches visited Giap on Monday as part of the commemorations. Giap told them the Dien Bien Phu victory had inspired other countries in their fight for freedom, the report said.

Phuong says he prefers the quiet comradeship of his mates who survived the battle, rather than grand celebrations.

For those who did not survive, he says he has made a habit of visiting their families on the anniversary of the victory to deliver a small gift and burn some incense for the dead.

"I miss my comrades," he says.

Copyright © 2009 AFP. All rights reserved.

Vietnam still struggles to find right staff

By Tim Johnston
Published: May 7 2009 01:54 | Last updated: May 7 2009 01:54

South-east Asia is reeling, as the global economic crisis chokes the exports that have driven the region’s extraordinary growth over the past decade. Hundreds of thousands of jobs have disappeared, yet there are some unexpected bright spots.

“There seems to be robust demand at the executive level,” says Lance Richards, a senior director at Kelly Outsourcing and Consulting, part of Kelly Services of the US. “What you are seeing is that unemployment is discriminatory to the unskilled and uneducated.”

He says that, across the region, areas such as finance, engineering, healthcare and human resources are still providing opportunities for people with the right qualifications.

He also notes that although employer demand has inevitably been hit by the slowdown, supplies of the right sort of employees remain tight.

“We don’t have a shortage of people, we have a shortage of talent,” says Mr Richards.

That is a particular problem in countries such as Vietnam.

At the beginning of last year, companies were struggling to find high-quality middle and upper management: engineers, human resources professionals, and finance directors were all in revolving-door jobs, their salaries sucked ever higher by the insatiable demands of both booming domestic companies and the hundreds of international investors moving to Vietnam to take advantage of its low-cost production base.

Even if the economy has since come back to earth with a bump, the veterans of these battles for talent are reluctant to let go of good employees.

And their reluctance has been fuelled by the Vietnamese government, which has responded to the crisis by trying to insulate industry with subsidised loans, tax holidays and trade finance: all in the hope that they will hold on to as much labour as they can until global demand starts to pick up.

But for companies working in developing and middle income countries in south-east Asia, the problem of talent shortage is likely to linger long after the current crisis is little more than a bitter memory.

“We don’t convert people into talent,” as Mr Richards bluntly sums it up. He says the core of the problem is that many universities in the region are providing the wrong sort of education.

“There are some world-class schools in the region, but many turn out graduates qualified in rote learning,” he says. “Their employability is abysmal.”

A survey conducted last year by the World Bank found that Vietnam should be turning out 10,000 skilled information technology graduates a year, but employers said that at least 60 per cent of new employees had to be retrained to bring them up to standard.

Intel, the computer chip manufacturer, needs to recruit some 3,000 employees for its new plant in Vietnam, but when it first went out into the market last year, of 1,965 students tested, only 320 passed the exam and only 90 – or 4.6 per cent – got more than 60 per cent.

Kieran Brennan, director of work and careers at the RMIT International University – part of the Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology – in Ho Chi Minh City, says that the survey is an extreme example, but Intel is not alone.

“Companies can find as many technical people as they want, but problem-solving and customer-facing staff can be hard to find,” he says.

Despite the slowdown, RMIT alumni are finding jobs.

“Our students are still relatively confident that there is a market for them,” says Mr Brennan.

One of RMIT’s clients, the accountancy firm KPMG, says that the situation is improving.

“The quality of graduates has improved considerably: not only in what they are learning at university, but in their mindset and their understanding of the outside world,” says Warrick Cleine, the managing partner of KPMG Vietnam.

He says that his firm recruited 300 graduates from 2,000 applicants last year, most of whom would have qualified. He says the company recently returned to the market to recruit 200 graduates for this year.

Staff turnover may have fallen, says Mr Cleine, but there is still a structural shortage of accountants in Vietnam.

When it comes to education, the country is by no means alone in its predicament.

The McKinsey Quarterly published a survey last year – before the global crisis began in earnest – which indicated that 44 per cent of companies headquartered in China thought that the lack of managerial talent was the biggest barrier to expansion outside the country.

This was significantly more than the 25 per cent that cited a lack of access to capital as their biggest problem.

The Vietnamese government sees education as the key to future prosperity and is pouring huge resources into schools and universities.

However, Mr Richards says that this and a promotion of critical thinking skills are unlikely to provide the solution: corporate culture also needs to change.

“If your business culture doesn’t demand leaders because the decision-making process is concentrated around one or two people, supply drops to match demand,” he says.

Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2009